Skip to Content
Home › Florida › Marathon › Precision Eye Care
PE
Optical shop Eye doctor ● Closed now Exams & optical on site Featured

Precision Eye Care

5800 Overseas Highway, Ste #43, Marathon, FL 33050

For all your eye care needs.

About

Precision Eye Care is an eye care practice in Marathon, Florida, located at 5800 Overseas Highway, Ste#43. Full optometry services include prescription eyeglasses, sunglasses, contact lenses, eye emergencies, dry eye specialty and treatment of eye diseases. We are here for all your eye care needs. Call 3057436939 to book your exam.

Listing type
Optical · Optometrist
Address
5800 Overseas Highway, Ste #43
Marathon, FL 33050
Get Directions
Phone
3057436939
Languages spoken
—
Walk-ins
By appointment only

Insurance accepted

Self-reported by the practice and last re-confirmed on 09/15/2026. Vision plans and medical plans are billed differently — call ahead to confirm which side of your coverage applies to your visit.

Services offered

✓ Dry eye treatment

Services not listed are not offered at this location.

Frame brands carried

Etnia Barcelona Gucci Lindberg Maui Jim ZEISS

Brands on the floor as of the practice's last update. Stock varies — call for a specific model.

Photos & videos 1

Photos and videos are supplied by the practice.

On the map

Hours

Monday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tuesday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wednesday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thursday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Friday 9:00 AM – 3:30 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed

Currently closed. Times shown in America/New_York. Holiday hours may differ.

Doctors at this practice

DN
Dr Nicole Cremata, OD
Optometrist
DR
Dr Reed West, OD
Optometrist

Reviews on Google 40

4.9
Based on 40 Google reviews
Powered by Google
Angela Sowers
Angela Sowers 2 months ago

As most people in the Keys, I'm from somewhere else, and so is my eye doctor. I stepped on my glasses, bending them all out of shape, so I stopped by Precision Eye Care to see if they could bend them back into shape, and they didn't hesitate. I was there for less than ten minutes, and left with perfectly fitting glasses- they wouldn't even let me pay them. If I lived here, they'd be my new place. They're awesome.

sarah caddigan
sarah caddigan 3 months ago

If I could give more stars I would!! Day one of vacation and my contact split in my eye, called them and spoke to Jennifer on the phone, she was so sweet and helpful and calmed me down through my panic, not only did she find me samples to take for vacation, but she called back to let me know and waited past closing for me to arrive. Once I arrived Jennifer had everything ready and her and her co worker were so pleasant, funny, and nothing short of class customer service. Cannot recommend them enough, I ordered two boxes of contacts and will be back to buy glasses before we leave.

Lauren Price
Lauren Price 9 months ago

Dr. Nicole Cremata is an exceptional eye doctor who truly goes above and beyond for her patients. She is extremely knowledgeable, thorough, and takes the time to explain everything in a clear and reassuring way. From the moment you walk into the office, you feel welcomed and well cared for. Dr. Cremata is attentive and patient, never rushed, and genuinely listens to concerns while offering thoughtful, personalized recommendations. Her professionalism and expertise inspire complete confidence, and it’s clear she is passionate about providing the highest level of care. I highly recommend Dr. Nicole Cremata to anyone looking for an outstanding eye doctor who combines skill, compassion, and excellent patient care.

Greg Fabrizzi
Greg Fabrizzi 2 months ago

I can’t say enough amazing things about the staff, the office and professionalism. I generally don’t do well in Doctor , dentist etc offices. I explained this to the staff and they made me feel the best I have ever felt in this type of setting. The entire staff again is amazing and Dr. West is just phenomenal. I highly recommend and actually look forward to a follow up exam. Thank you all

Danielle Permenter
Danielle Permenter 3 months ago

After quitting contacts for a couple years, Dr Nicole took the time to figure out my goals with contacts and said she could help. Now I love love love my contacts after 2 other optometrists told me that they couldn’t make it better. Thank you so much!

See all reviews on Google

Reviews are written by Google users and shown as published on Google. EyecareSearch does not edit, verify or rank them.

EyecareSearch is a directory service. We do not provide medical advice, verify clinical outcomes, or guarantee insurance coverage. Plan participation is self-reported by each practice — always confirm benefits directly with your plan and the practice before your visit.