Skip to Content
Unclaimed listing. Compiled from public sources — not supplied or checked by the practice.
Is this your practice?
Home › New York › Smithtown › Brookhaven Opticians
BO
Optical shop Eye doctor ● Closed now Details not recently confirmed Exams & optical on site

Brookhaven Opticians

79 E Main St Ste D, Smithtown, NY 11787-2867

About

Brookhaven Opticians is an eye doctor and optical shop in Smithtown, New York, located at 79 E Main St Ste D. Eye exams and an optical dispensary are both on site, so you can have your eyes checked and pick out frames in one visit. Listed services include glasses & frames, contact lenses, contact lens fitting and sports & safety eyewear. The practice is in network with 12 vision plans, including EyeMed, Davis Vision, Superior Vision and Aetna Vision. Care is provided by Barnett Schrier, OD. It is open 6 days a week, including Saturdays. Walk-ins are accepted. Call (631) 265-5767 to confirm hours and coverage before you visit.

Listing type
Optical · Optometrist
Address
79 E Main St Ste D
Smithtown, NY 11787-2867
Get Directions
Phone
(631) 265-5767
Languages spoken
—
Walk-ins
Accepted

Insurance accepted

✓ EyeMed ✓ Davis Vision ✓ Superior Vision ✓ Aetna Vision ✓ Cigna Vision ✓ Humana Vision ✓ Humana Vision PLUS ✓ Humana Focus / Optimum / Advantage ✓ Humana Medicare Advantage ✓ Humana Medicare Supplement ✓ Superior Vision – Medicare ✓ Superior Vision – Medicaid
Self-reported by the practice. These details have not been confirmed yet. Vision plans and medical plans are billed differently — call ahead to confirm which side of your coverage applies to your visit.

Services offered

✓ Comprehensive eye exam
✓ Glasses & frames
✓ Contact lens fitting
✓ Sports & safety eyewear

Services not listed are not offered at this location.

Frame brands carried

This is a clinical practice with no retail optical. Your prescription can be filled at any optical shop — see shops in Smithtown.

On the map

Hours

Monday 9:15 AM – 5:45 PM
Tuesday 9:15 AM – 5:45 PM
Wednesday 9:15 AM – 5:45 PM
Thursday 9:15 AM – 5:45 PM
Friday 9:15 AM – 5:45 PM
Saturday 9:15 AM – 4:30 PM

Currently closed. Times shown in America/New_York. Holiday hours may differ.

Doctors at this practice

PM
Paul Mastrorocco, OP
Optician
Male Speaks English, Spanish, Italian
Licence 005855 (NY)
BS
Barnett Schrier, OD
Male
Licence TUV002801-1 (NY)

Reviews on Google 45

4.9
Based on 45 Google reviews
Powered by Google
Jeannie w
Jeannie w 4 months ago

I was completely amazed how much care I was getting from Paul, the optician. He spent endless time and energy educating me and explaining the importance of the medical needs of the lenses and measurements. I realized that this affects my complete body composition of walking and pain from muscle aches etc. I am so pleased that he corrected my eyesight since I received the beautiful glasses. I will continue to follow up as needed since he is so welcoming.

Fred Walter
Fred Walter 7 months ago

Walked in to search for my first pair of glasses ever. Was greeted by Scott who immediately put me at ease knowledgeably answering all my questions and guiding me through the vast inventory of glasses. He patiently helped me try on dozens and dozens of pairs and helped me narrow my focus on the perfect pairs. He got everything put together for me and contacted me the second they were in. Scott was a pleasure to work with and I appreciate he and all the folks at Brookhaven Opticians. Highly recommend checking them out.

Jacqueline Meyer
Jacqueline Meyer 6 months ago

Scott is very informative, patient and helpful! He assisted in my finding perfect frames! I am very happy with his service and recommend going to him! Sincerely Mrs. Thompson.

Blue J
Blue J a year ago

I had a fantastic experience at Brookhaven Opticians in Smithtown, thanks to Scott! He was incredibly helpful from start to finish — not only was he patient while my mom and I took our time picking out frames, but he also went above and beyond to help us find options we were truly happy with. On top of that, Scott worked hard to get us the best price possible, which we really appreciated. His professionalism, kindness, and attention to detail made the whole process smooth and enjoyable. Highly recommend asking for Scott if you're visiting!

Harvey Beckwith
Harvey Beckwith 10 months ago

Paul and Scott at Brookhaven Opticians were absolutely wonderful. This was my first experience with their service and found that their expertise In eye ware helped me to select the glasses that fit my needs exactly. Because of my double vision problem I needed my glasses to be made to exact specifications. Not only did my new glasses meet my requirements they were able to have them made in record time. Their personal attention is second to none with follow up phone calls to check on my satisfaction. I highly recommend them to anyone who is looking for a complete personal and professional eye ware experience. You won’t be disappointed!

See all reviews on Google

Reviews are written by Google users and shown as published on Google. EyecareSearch does not edit, verify or rank them.

EyecareSearch is a directory service. We do not provide medical advice, verify clinical outcomes, or guarantee insurance coverage. Plan participation is self-reported by each practice — always confirm benefits directly with your plan and the practice before your visit.