Skip to Content
Unclaimed listing. Compiled from public sources — not supplied or checked by the practice.
Is this your practice?
Home › Indiana › Indianapolis › MyEyeDr
M
Optical shop Eye doctor ● Closed now Details not recently confirmed Exams & optical on site

MyEyeDr

4.3

MyEyeDr serves patients in Indianapolis and the surrounding part of Indiana from its office at 2902 W 86th St Ste 160. Both exams and glasses are handled here — exam rooms and an optical shop share the same address. Listed services include glasses & frames, contact lenses, contact lens fitting and sports & safety eyewear. Insurance accepted includes VSP, EyeMed, Davis Vision and Superior Vision (15 plans in total). 18 doctors are listed here, including Abby Butorac, OD, Jacquelin J. Thompson, OD and Brian Ross, OD.

Address
2902 W 86th St Ste 160
Indianapolis, IN 46268-2196
Get Directions
Phone
(317) 337-1233
Languages spoken
English
Walk-ins
Accepted

Insurance accepted

✓ VSP Vision Care ✓ EyeMed ✓ Davis Vision ✓ Superior Vision ✓ Aetna Vision ✓ Cigna Vision ✓ Medicare ✓ Humana Vision ✓ Humana Vision PLUS ✓ Humana Focus / Optimum / Advantage ✓ Humana Medicare Advantage ✓ Humana Medicare Supplement ✓ Superior Vision – ACA ✓ Superior Select ✓ Superior Select Midwest ✓ Superior Select Southwest
Compiled from the vision plans' public provider directories — not yet confirmed by the practice. Networks change, so call ahead to confirm your plan is accepted. Vision plans and medical plans are billed differently — call ahead to confirm which side of your coverage applies to your visit.

Services offered

✓ Comprehensive eye exam
✓ Glasses & frames
✓ Contact lens fitting
✓ Sports & safety eyewear

Services shown are the ones this practice has listed with us. Contact the practice to ask about anything not shown.

Frame brands carried

Airlock Anne Klein AVIO bebe Calvin Klein Canada Goose Cole Haan Columbia Converse Cutler and Gross DKNY Donna Karan Dragon Draper James Ferragamo Flexon Genesis JOE Joseph Abboud Karl Lagerfeld Kendra Scott Lacoste Lenton & Rusby Linda Farrow Longchamp Marchon McAllister Nautica Nike Vision Nine West Otis & Piper Paul Smith Pure Spyder ZEISS

Not confirmed by the practice. Brands commonly available through this practice's vision networks and frame suppliers — call to check before you visit.

Hours

Hours not published — call ahead.

Currently closed. Times shown in America/New_York. Holiday hours may differ.

Doctors at this practice

AB
Abby Butorac, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 18003727B (IN) NPI 1033471818
JT
Jacqueline Thompson, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 18003464A (IN) NPI 1881890705
BR
Brian Ross, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 18003235B (IN) NPI 1144213786
DM
David Millikan, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 18002831A (IN) NPI 1144240706
MA
Meagan Avila, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 18003534A (IN) NPI 1144485749
JA
Judson Avila, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 18003539A (IN) NPI 1205035037
SS
Shilpa Shah, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 18003667B (IN) NPI 1336472661
KS
Kathryn Smith, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 18003431A (IN) NPI 1427136662
LK
Larry Koval, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 180002079B (IN) NPI 1770503914
SP
Shannon Pierce, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 18002431B (IN) NPI 1871678417
AR
Andrea Risley, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 18004047A (IN) NPI 1982126033
JT
John Till, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 18004036A (IN) NPI 1932639929
NC
Nathaniel Clark, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 18004088A (IN) NPI 1144712035
SM
Sean Mcgrath, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 18004043A (IN) NPI 1841712841
NH
Nicholas Helderman, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 18003910A (IN) NPI 1629450861
OF
Olivia Forthofer, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 18004189A (IN) NPI 1356997993
JC
Jackson Clark, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 18004592A (IN) NPI 1245022540

On the map

Reviews on Google 127

4.3
Based on 127 Google reviews
Powered by Google
weirdpasta
weirdpasta 3 months ago

Great experience from start to finish! Jordyn was so welcoming and made check-in quick and easy. The rest of the staff was friendly and made the whole visit a pleasant one. I always struggle with picking out glasses for myself but Steven was able to help me pick out not one but two perfect pairs. They even gave me 40% off the second pair! Highly recommend MyEyeDr!

Jerome Mayden
Jerome Mayden 3 months ago

Love Dr. Avilia- But the store is not worth it. Complained about the cost of glasses being too high and then magically my insurance was ran a different way and it became 50% less. Called back to have a recheck for contacts quoted $50 and to wait 2 weeks. Called back and the price jumped to $174. BBB complaint is the next step. I understand needing to make money as a business but this is just not sitting well with me. See the Dr. but be careful purchasing anything from here. Buyer beware! Looking at the past comments - this seems to be an on going issue. SMH sad practice for a medical provider.

Kaitlyn Kendrick
Kaitlyn Kendrick 3 months ago

I’ve been to a lot of optometry offices over the years, and this MyEyeDr location is one of the few that truly makes you feel like more than just another appointment on the schedule. From the moment I walked in, everyone was welcoming, organized, and genuinely happy to help. The entire visit was smooth from check-in to checkout. The staff took the time to answer my questions, explained everything clearly, and never made me feel rushed. It’s obvious they value providing great patient care. If you’re looking for an eye doctor with excellent customer service and an office that actually makes going to the eye doctor a pleasant experience, I highly recommend this MyEyeDr on W 86th. They earned a lifelong patient!

Eva Corsaro
Eva Corsaro a month ago

I’ve been going to the Eye Doctor on W 86th Street next to the Trader Joe’s for 8 years. My last visit with Dr Judson Avila was on May 21. I had a change in my eyes so I had to get new lenses. After I picked up my new lenses I noticed the tint wasn’t getting dark enough. When I went outside I noticed I was squinting and I was feeling blinded by the sun. My previous glasses were dark enough to where I didn’t see my eyes. I did return to the store and was told it’s cloudy outside. I told him I’ve had the new glasses for 2 weeks and several days have been sunny. Dr Avila is a wonderful doctor. However, the turnover of employees who help you order your glasses hasn’t been great. I’ve also had problems getting my frames adjusted with my hearing aids. The two women who worked previously before these two men knew exactly what I needed for my frames to fit with my hearing aids. The men who work there don’t listen to me. Please someone help me.

Christie Lafontant
Christie Lafontant 2 months ago

This business does not submit all the claims to the insurance provider. I went to this office to get lenses for my glasses and contact lenses while having insurance. They told me that I have to pay over 400 dollars as co pay which I did. But three months later to the date of which I went there, I got a call from a collection agency stated I owe 84 dollars more because of insurance kick back. I immediately called my insurance to verify that I had a kick back for real and they told me that they only show a claim for my regular lenses and the amount that I had to pay was just a fraction of what I actually had to pay as a co pay. I was also sent to collections without being notified of the bill; I didn’t even have a change to verify anything up until after I was sent to collections 3 months later. So they basically lied about submitting all the claims to the insurance and made me pay the contact lenses out of pocket and still claim there’s an insurance kick back for it when they didn’t submit the claim for real. Please can someone make sure this does that happen again ? Because they did the same “false kick back” situation to my sister as well and I’m worried this is gonna keep happening to a lot of people without even knowing. I am still trying to resolve this but they’re saying there’s nothing more they can do for me after submitting the information to their billing department. I have recorded all the calls I had with them and I hope my credit doesn’t get ruined over this.

See all reviews on Google

Reviews are written by Google users and shown as published on Google. EyecareSearch does not edit, verify or rank them.

EyecareSearch is a directory service. We do not provide medical advice, verify clinical outcomes, or guarantee insurance coverage. Plan participation is self-reported by each practice — always confirm benefits directly with your plan and the practice before your visit.