Skip to Content
Unclaimed listing. Compiled from public sources — not supplied or checked by the practice.
Is this your practice?
Home › New York › Brewster › MyEyeDr
M
Optical shop Eye doctor ● Open now Details not recently confirmed Exams & optical on site

MyEyeDr

4.7

Located at 1577 Route 22 in Brewster, NY, MyEyeDr is an eye doctor and optical shop serving the Brewster area. The practice offers both eye exams and eyewear, which means prescriptions can be filled without a second trip. Listed services include glasses & frames, contact lenses, contact lens fitting and pediatric eye care. VSP, EyeMed, Davis Vision and Superior Vision are among the 19 vision plans accepted. 7 doctors are listed here, including Artis Beatty, OD, Robert Greenbaum, OD and Justine Mcgeary, OD. It is open 5 days a week, including Saturdays.

Address
1577 Route 22
Brewster, NY 10509-4010
Get Directions
Phone
(845) 279-6179
Languages spoken
English
Walk-ins
Accepted

Insurance accepted

✓ Metlife Vision - Federal Vision Plan (FEDVIP) ✓ VSP Vision Care ✓ EyeMed ✓ Davis Vision ✓ Superior Vision ✓ Spectera / UnitedHealthcare ✓ Aetna Vision ✓ Cigna Vision ✓ Medicare ✓ Humana Vision ✓ Humana Vision PLUS ✓ Humana Focus / Optimum / Advantage ✓ Humana Medicare Advantage ✓ Humana Medicare Supplement ✓ MetLife Vision ✓ Superior Vision – Medicare ✓ Superior Vision – ACA ✓ Superior Select ✓ Superior Select Midwest ✓ Superior Select Southwest
Compiled from the vision plans' public provider directories — not yet confirmed by the practice. Networks change, so call ahead to confirm your plan is accepted. Vision plans and medical plans are billed differently — call ahead to confirm which side of your coverage applies to your visit.

Services offered

✓ Comprehensive eye exam
✓ Glasses & frames
✓ Contact lens fitting
✓ Pediatric eye care
✓ Sports & safety eyewear

Services shown are the ones this practice has listed with us. Contact the practice to ask about anything not shown.

Frame brands carried

Airlock Anne Klein AVIO bebe Calvin Klein Canada Goose Cole Haan Columbia Converse Cutler and Gross DKNY Donna Karan Dragon Draper James Ferragamo Flexon Genesis JOE Joseph Abboud Karl Lagerfeld Kendra Scott Lacoste Lenton & Rusby Linda Farrow Longchamp Marchon McAllister Nautica Nike Vision Nine West Otis & Piper Paul Smith Pure Spyder ZEISS

Not confirmed by the practice. Brands commonly available through this practice's vision networks and frame suppliers — call to check before you visit.

Hours

Monday 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tuesday 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thursday 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Friday 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Saturday 8:00 AM – 2:00 PM

Currently open — closes at 5:00 PM. Times shown in America/New_York. Holiday hours may differ.

Doctors at this practice

AB
Artis Beatty, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 8521 (NY) NPI 1972567006
RG
Robert Greenbaum, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 4414 (NY) NPI 1750387973
JM
Justine Mcgeary, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 009403 (NY) NPI 1073286340
GW
Gabrielle White, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 9425 (NY) NPI 1356017081
JS
Joseph Stallone, OD
Optometrist
Male Speaks English
License 9628 (NY) NPI 1003556762
GK
Gurkiran Kaur, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 009656 (NY) NPI 1144957366
ER
Eleni Romanelli, OD
Optometrist
Female Speaks English
License 009778 (NY) NPI 1972290914

On the map

Reviews on Google 68

4.7
Based on 68 Google reviews
Powered by Google
Terriann Albrecht
Terriann Albrecht 2 months ago

Excellent customer service. Nice staff. Everyone is pleasant. Dr. Romanelli is kind and a good listener, for people who need a through eye exam. This isn't the same exam as Walmart. Any issues with blurry vision and you need more advanced care and technology. Time to buy a frame: Even the $145.00 glasses turned into $350.00. I purchased 3 pairs of glasses and each one came to $350.00 with all discounts and with different packages. One frame of glasses are flexible (flex) and special glasses for playing golf. One frame of glasses (for going out working)- looking fashionable (Raybans) my favorite and go to glasses. They have cheaper frames that range from $95.00 to $145.00 still cost me $350.00. I needed a heavy frame less stylish for gardening and some temperature changes at work. But- I didn't want to spend $350.00. People on a budget need to ask a lot of questions. Have the sales team show you a couple packages. Make sure you get your "eye script" and compare some less expensive frames in other places (even glasses online)for people who need glasses on a budget. Maybe you have children. This can get expensive. It's hard times out here folks. Im going to buy a couple pairs of glasses online and find the best prices for people on a fixed income. Keep an eye 👁 out for my posts.

Amit Ohri
Amit Ohri 2 months ago

I recently visited the MyEyeDr. office in Brewster, NY for an eye exam and to order new glasses, and I had an outstanding experience thanks to Joseph Macchia. Joseph was incredibly patient, knowledgeable, and professional throughout the entire process. He took the time to answer all of my questions, helped me choose a great pair of frames, and never made me feel rushed. Even when I called to check on the status of my glasses, he was courteous and helpful. When I returned to pick them up, he carefully adjusted the frames to ensure they fit perfectly and made sure I was completely satisfied. Excellent customer service is hard to find these days, and Joseph truly went above and beyond. Thank you for making the entire experience so pleasant!

Alexandra
Alexandra 2 months ago

Dr. Romanelli and the staff of the Brewster MyEyeCare are all wonderful. Dr. Romanelli takes the time to explain things in easily understandable terms, does a thorough eye exam, and you can tell that she really cares about her patients and their eye care. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable to make both the check-in and checkout a smooth process.

Nick
Nick 11 months ago

Went for a very overdue eye exam to update my contact lens Rx and everyone here was very kind, helpful & professional. I booked an appointment online, was seen on time & they took time to help me understand my vision insurance benefits better so I got the best use of my plan's coverage for new glasses and contact lenses. Overall great experience. I'll be returning for my annual eye exam next year. Highly recommended.

Lorien Vidal
Lorien Vidal 8 months ago

If this review was just for the doctor and the lovely gentleman who helped me pick out glasses, it would be 5 stars. I had a Saturday appointment a few months ago which started off great. I did all the tests and got my eyes dilated, so it wasn't a super-quick visit. The problem arose when the young lady was ringing me up. I had just applied for CareCredit and she was having trouble getting it to go through. Prior to the appointment I confirmed that CareCredit was accepted there. I called CareCredit for assistance and they reported no issue on their end and they also saw no attempts to charge my account, which was puzzling. I apologized to the young lady and asked if I could put down a partial payment on my debit card. I was shocked to hear her say "Yeah, we really have to close up" after grudgingly agreeing to take my payment. She seemed annoyed. I thanked them and left after making my payment. I wound up calling a few days later to cancel my order for the eyeglasses. I felt bad, since the same gentleman who helped me pick out glasses was assisting with this, and he asked what happened. I didn't say anything about the impatient girl who made it my problem they had to stay "late" that day. When I went to use my CareCredit at a veterinarian appointment the following week, I found out that the young lady from MyEyeDr wasn't doing it correctly. It can't be processed through the credit card machine & she should have known that; instead of getting impatient with me like I was just there to waste time. Had it not been for the sour ending, I would have praised her for how sweet she was during my tests.

See all reviews on Google

Reviews are written by Google users and shown as published on Google. EyecareSearch does not edit, verify or rank them.

EyecareSearch is a directory service. We do not provide medical advice, verify clinical outcomes, or guarantee insurance coverage. Plan participation is self-reported by each practice — always confirm benefits directly with your plan and the practice before your visit.