Skip to Content
Home › Florida › Fort Myers › Underhill Eyecare
UE
Optical shop Eye doctor ● Closed now Exams & optical on site Featured

Underhill Eyecare

1565 Matthew Dr, Ste 2, Fort Myers, FL 33907

Request Appointment

About

Underhill Eyecare serves patients in Fort Myers and the surrounding parts of Lee County from its office at 1565 Matthew Dr. Both exams and glasses are handled here — exam rooms and an optical shop share the same address. Listed services include comprehensive eye exam, glasses & frames, contact lenses and contact lens fitting. Insurance accepted includes Eyemed, VSP, Davis Vision, Superior Vision and Spectera and select others. Care is provided by Thomas Underhill, OD. The optical carries a variety of frame brands. It is open 4 days a week. You can walk in without an appointment for optical services but all exams need an appointment. Call (239) 482-0355 to confirm hours and coverage before you visit.

Listing type
Optical · Optometrist
Address
1565 Matthew Dr
Ste 2
Fort Myers, FL 33907
Get Directions
Phone
(239) 482-0355
Languages spoken
English
Walk-ins
By appointment only

Insurance accepted

✓ Metlife Vision - Federal Vision Plan (FEDVIP) ✓ VSP Vision Care ✓ EyeMed ✓ Davis Vision ✓ Superior Vision ✓ Spectera / UnitedHealthcare ✓ Aetna Vision ✓ Cigna Vision ✓ Humana Vision ✓ Humana Vision PLUS
Self-reported by the practice and last re-confirmed on 09/11/2026. Vision plans and medical plans are billed differently — call ahead to confirm which side of your coverage applies to your visit.

Services offered

✓ Comprehensive eye exam
✓ Glasses & frames
✓ Contact lens fitting
✓ Pediatric eye care
✓ Dry eye treatment

Services not listed are not offered at this location.

Frame brands carried

Coach Costa Del Mar DKNY Ferragamo Marchon Oakley Ray-Ban

Brands on the floor as of the practice's last update. Stock varies — call for a specific model.

On the map

Hours

Tuesday 7:30 AM – 5:30 PM
Wednesday 7:30 AM – 5:30 PM
Thursday 7:30 AM – 5:30 PM
Friday 7:30 AM – 5:30 PM

Currently closed. Times shown in America/New_York. Holiday hours may differ.

Doctors at this practice

TU
Thomas Underhill, OD
10 years in practice

Reviews on Google 347

4.9
Based on 347 Google reviews
Powered by Google
beccat24
beccat24 7 months ago

After his father’s retirement, I knew that I would certainly keep my eye records with his son. Young Dr. Underhill was personable and extremely thorough when looking at the tests that I had undergone that day. He also was able to explain to me what the test results meant in a manner in which I could understand. I was impressed with the state of the art equipment that he used to do the various tests of my eyes, including photos. This was more than an eye exam for glasses. I feel that my eyes are in great care. I would recommend him to anyone in need of an eye exam.

Suri Sehgal
Suri Sehgal 7 months ago

I had an appointment with Dr Tom Underhill yesterday. I was impressed with the new facility, professionalism of the staff and thorough examination by Dr Underhill. Dr Underhill took time to listen to me and after the exam gave me an update of what he observed. I was a bit rushed but he was not. It was opposite of what one experiences with other doctors. Dr's assistant was equally patient and exhibited professionalism. Suri Sehgal. 1/22/2026

G A
G A 10 months ago

I went to Underhill eye associates for the first time this past Friday. I was seen promptly. The eye exam was thorough and organized. The doctor was attentive, patient, and detailed. He answered all of my questions with care. I will be using this office for all my eye care needs going forward.

tim leffler
tim leffler 8 months ago

Superior service, care and customer experience! You guys saved my eye, eased my pain and got me back to work. 🙏🏼 Thank you!

Sherri Rowan
Sherri Rowan a month ago

My husband and I have been going here for a few years , and has always been a pleasant experience!

See all reviews on Google

Reviews are written by Google users and shown as published on Google. EyecareSearch does not edit, verify or rank them.

More like this

EyecareSearch is a directory service. We do not provide medical advice, verify clinical outcomes, or guarantee insurance coverage. Plan participation is self-reported by each practice — always confirm benefits directly with your plan and the practice before your visit.