Skip to Content
Unclaimed listing. Compiled from public sources — not supplied or checked by the practice.
Is this your practice?
Home › New York › Trumansburg › Dr Neil Henninger
DN
Optical shop Eye doctor ● Closed now Details not recently confirmed Exams & optical on site

Dr Neil Henninger

11 E Main St, Trumansburg, NY 14886

About

Dr Neil Henninger is an eye doctor and optical shop in Trumansburg, New York, located at 11 E Main St. Eye exams and an optical dispensary are both on site, so you can have your eyes checked and pick out frames in one visit. Listed services include glasses & frames, contact lenses, contact lens fitting and sports & safety eyewear. The practice is in network with 12 vision plans, including VSP, EyeMed, Davis Vision and Aetna Vision. Doctors at this practice include Neil F. Henninger, OD and Samantha Goodenough, OD. The optical carries 36 frame brands. Walk-ins are accepted. Call (607) 387-7327 to confirm hours and coverage before you visit.

Listing type
Optical · Optometrist
Address
11 E Main St
Trumansburg, NY 14886
Get Directions
Phone
(607) 387-7327
Languages spoken
English
Walk-ins
Accepted

Insurance accepted

✓ Metlife Vision - Federal Vision Plan (FEDVIP) ✓ VSP Vision Care ✓ EyeMed ✓ Davis Vision ✓ Aetna Vision ✓ Cigna Vision ✓ Humana Vision ✓ Humana Vision PLUS ✓ Humana Focus / Optimum / Advantage ✓ Humana Medicare Advantage ✓ Humana Medicare Supplement
Self-reported by the practice. These details have not been confirmed yet. Vision plans and medical plans are billed differently — call ahead to confirm which side of your coverage applies to your visit.

Services offered

✓ Comprehensive eye exam
✓ Glasses & frames
✓ Contact lens fitting
✓ Sports & safety eyewear

Services not listed are not offered at this location.

Frame brands carried

Airlock Anne Klein AVIO bebe Calvin Klein Canada Goose Cole Haan Columbia Converse Cutler and Gross DKNY Donna Karan Dragon Draper James Ferragamo Flexon Genesis JOE Joseph Abboud Karl Lagerfeld Kendra Scott Lacoste Lenton & Rusby Linda Farrow Longchamp Marchon McAllister Nautica Nike Vision Nine West Otis & Piper Paul Smith Pure Spyder ZEISS

Brands on the floor as of the practice's last update. Stock varies — call for a specific model.

On the map

Hours

Hours not published — call ahead.

Currently closed. Times shown in America/New_York. Holiday hours may differ.

Doctors at this practice

NF
Neil F. Henninger, OD
Male
Licence 005362 (NY)
SG
Samantha Goodenough, OD
Female
Licence 008820 (NY)

Reviews on Google 15

4.3
Based on 15 Google reviews
Powered by Google
Sheila Kissiloff
Sheila Kissiloff 3 years ago

My entire family has been patients of TO since we moved to Trumansburg. Dr. Neil, Karen, and Izzie are exactly what a hometown family owned business should be; friendly, knowledgeable, caring, experts in their field with up to date technology, and the added bonus of knowing everyone by name. Kind of like “Cheers,” Besides the typical professional care during routine eye exam visits, their “extras” (but perhaps not for them), put them in the “above and beyond” category. One of my sons wanted to wear contacts when playing hockey, Karen spent what seemed like hours teaching him how to put them in. I mean with patience, grace, calm, and humor. I’d like to know if anyone from the large chain eye practices would do that. Whenever we need a “fix” of some sort on glasses, whether we bought them there or not, they are willing to fix them, just walk in. They will help with a smile. I’m thankful they are open on Saturdays to accommodate the working folks who can’t get there during the work week. That’s one of the things an awesome practice will do; be accommodating as possible to the needs of their clients. Thanks Trumansburg Optical!

Emma Plotkin
Emma Plotkin 2 years ago

This place is wonderful. The person upfront is extremely warm and very helpful. They really work with you to find the best fit. The doctor did a great job. I appreciated the high tech instruments that weren't at my old doctors office as they were more comfortable to use.

Brooke Collins
Brooke Collins 6 years ago

I had a wonderful experience with Dr. Goodman. She was very thorough; kind and I was very impressed with her. She went as far as letting me try a new type contacts before billing my insurance. She also was able to identify problems with my retina that previous Dr.’s have missed. Would give 10 stars if I could!

C T
C T 6 years ago

Positive: Friendly staff. Plus there was no pupil dilation with drops was required. Negative: Was diagnosed incorrectly with wrong contact and eyeglass prescriptions for a couple of years. Even went back for adjustment and to check eyes again but it didn’t help. Went to Optivision in Cortland and got correct prescription which was weaker then was diagnosed with at Tburg Optical. Which is why my vision was blurry...prescription was too strong! And also received the correct contacts for astigmatism. I can finally see again! Every time I had a vision exam at Tburg Optical my vision so happened to get worse. Coincidence?! I hope not but wonder if that’s how they try to make more money since I’d have to get new glasses and contacts. That or their doctor or machines aren’t accurate. Also incorrectly told about my insurance benefits coverage. Telling me that I had to order glasses or contacts that same day as my exam or would lose benefit. I called insurance company and had 90 days. Convenient days/hours but any good doctor shouldn’t have to work on a Saturday. That’s what I was told by a good eye doctor.

Luke Fenchel
Luke Fenchel 3 years ago

Last week my two year old and four year old had a tug-of-war with my glasses - it was a spectacle (sorry!) that left my frames certainly worse for the wear, if not totally unwearable. Within a week Neil and company had me able to see clearly again without having to look like Eustace Tilley. Prompt, professional, empathetic - I’m happy to say that now I have an anecdote and not a headache!

See all reviews on Google

Reviews are written by Google users and shown as published on Google. EyecareSearch does not edit, verify or rank them.

EyecareSearch is a directory service. We do not provide medical advice, verify clinical outcomes, or guarantee insurance coverage. Plan participation is self-reported by each practice — always confirm benefits directly with your plan and the practice before your visit.